The Cardinals went with a number of lineups last year, often trying different people at virtually every spot of the lineup except the No. 3 hole. However, for the most part, the lineup stayed the same. It will most likely be the same way this season with really only one new face being added to the mix.
Here’s my predictions of how the lineup will shape up this season, as well as my breakdown of each player:
1.) Skip Schumaker, 2B – Schumaker did well adjusting to new roles last season. After moving from the outfield to play second base for the first time, he was thrown in to the lead off spot after the Cardinals found themselves without a “true” leadoff hitter. Schumaker adjusted well, hitting above .300 with four home runs and 35 RBI. This marked the third straight season that Schumaker had hit over .300, and the second straight year that he played 153 games. With the new contract that was given to him, the Cardinals are looking for the same type of production out of him at the top of the lineup this year that they saw last year. The only real knocks on Schumaker as a lead off guy is that his on-base percentage isn’t as high as other leadoff hitters and he doesn’t steal many bases. However, with a .364 OBP and just two stolen bases, Schumaker still scored 85 runs, the second most on the team. His run total will improve with the off-season improvements made by the guy who hits behind him, Colby Rasmus.
2.) Colby Rasmus, CF – Rasmus put together one of the top seasons among National League Rookies last season. He hit played in 147 games, hitting .251 with 16 home runs and 52 RBI. He struggled mainly with left-handed pitching last season, so he didn’t start many games if a lefty was on the mound. He was also hindered with an injury, which slowed down his production. But Rasmus has been working with new Hitting Coach Mark McGwire this off-season and has vastly improved his hitting against lefties, making a more potent offensive option hitting in between Schumaker and Albert Pujols. But like Schumaker, Rasmus didn’t provide much speed on the base paths last season at the top of the lineup, only stealing three bases. That’s certainly something he and Schumaker will have to improve upon if the Cardinals want to win. More runners in scoring position for Albert Pujols can only mean positive things.
3.) Albert Pujols, 1B – To put it simply, the team doesn’t win without him. Pujols is coming off his third MVP season where he led the Major Leagues with 47 home runs and was third in RBI with 135, despite being third in the Majors in walks with 115 walks, 44 of which were intentional. He also led the Majors in runs with 124. With a full season of protection by All-Star caliber outfielder Matt Holliday, it’s scary to think what kind of numbers Pujols will put up in 2010.
Food for thought: In his nine Major League seasons, Pujols has never hit below .300, less than 30 home runs, or drove in less than 100 RBI. He also surprised everyone last season when he tied his career-high stolen base mark of 16 stolen bases that he set in 2005. With these 16 stolen bases, Pujols actually led the team in steals.
4.) Matt Holliday, LF – After receiving a lucrative deal that was actually more expensive than the new Busch Stadium, Matt Holliday is going to be expected to justify every bit of that seven-year, $120 million deal. But if his 2010 season is anything like the 63 games he played with the Cardinals last season, I don’t think he’ll have anything to worry about. He hit .353 with the Redbirds with 13 home runs and 55 RBI. He hit 24 total home runs and drove in a total of 101 RBI in 2009. Holliday is the first real protection that Albert Pujols has had in a while, and it seemed to work out extremely well last season for the Cardinals.
Food for thought: Holliday played in 30 less games as a Cardinal uniform than he did in Oakland, but actually hit more home runs and drove in more runs in St. Louis. In his 93 games with Oakland, he he hit 11 home runs with 54 RBI. He hit 13 home runs and 55 RBI with the Cardinals. I think it’s safe to say that Holliday likes to face National League pitching.
5.) Ryan Ludwick, RF – He’s the kicker for this offense. As mentioned in my previous post, if he can perform like he did in 2008 where hit .299 with 37 home runs, the Cardinals’ 3-4-5 could easily be one of the best in baseball. He struggled at times last year, though, only hitting .265 over the course of the season, his lowest batting average since being traded to St. Louis from Cleveland. He’ll have plenty of RBI opportunities hitting behind Rasmus, Pujols, and Holliday.
6.) David Freese, 3B – With Mark DeRosa departing for San Francisco this off-season, David Freese appears to be the heir-apparent to take over at third base. The young infielder was the projected starter at third base last season, but was passed up for Brian Barden and ended up playing  just 17 games with the Big League club before spending the rest of the season in Triple-A. He had one home run and seven RBI while in St. Louis, showing that he can hit Major League pitching. He suffered an injury in spring training and decided to have surgery mid-season, which shortened his Triple-A season to just 56 games. While at Triple-A Memphis, he hit .300 with 10 home runs and 37 RBI. Freese, who was traded to the Cardinals prior to the 2008 season in the deal for Jim Edmonds, will have to put his off-season legal troubles behind him and focus on baseball in 2010. He was arrested on December 12 on suspicion of driving while intoxicated.
7.) Yadier Molina, C - Molina isn’t known for his offense, but quietly hovered near a .3o0 batting average last season. The defensive specialist clubbed six home runs and 54 RBI in 2009, solid numbers for a catcher. He won’t be relied upon to contribute too heavily on offense, but he seems to make strides in hitting each year. An slight increase in production from Molina wouldn’t be out of the question for 2010.
8.) Pitcher – Tony La Russa is one of the few, if not the only, managers in the league that hits the pitcher eighth. There’s actually a method to the madness, though. He does this in order to have a decent hitter hitting ninth to essentially created a second lead off spot to possibly get three runners on base for Albert Pujols.
9.) Brendan Ryan, SS – Ryan sort of came in to his own at the end of the 2009 season offensively, and ended the season with a .292 average with three home runs and 37 RBI. Ryan appears to be the only base-stealing threat that Cardinals have right now, given his pure speed. He also stole 14 bases last season on 21 attempts. But it’s his hitting that has made the seen the most improvement this off-season. Like Rasmus, Ryan is a beneficiary of Mark McGwire’s arrival as hitting coach. Holliday, Schumaker, and Ryan had already been working out with McGwire in the off-season before McGwire was hired, but Ryan is taking full advantage of McGwire’s knowledge. Several reports have stated that Ryan has been hitting every day this off-season with McGwire and has improved twice as much in hitting.
The Cardinals will look to repeat as NL Central champions again in 2010. With an improved Colby Rasmus and Brendan Ryan, as well as a full season of Matt Holliday, the Cardinals are the sure favorites to win the division.